This article intervenes in a long historiographic tradition of scholarship surrounding the 1735 trial of New York City printer John Peter Zenger, but (unlike most scholarship) it focuses on the larger episode of which the Zenger trial was a part: what I collectively call "The Cosby Affair," named after the imperial governor whose administration in New York caused a populist uprising that threatened the stability of the colony's social and political fabric. For generations, the critical conversation has centered on Zenger's trial, with historians and legal scholars continually debating the trial's causes and effects and its importance in the history of the freedom of the press.
The article's analysis of the Cosby Affair intervenes in those debates by analyzing not just the prosaic essays and letters of Zenger's New-York Weekly Journal, which was the mouthpiece of the populist movement, formed in response to Governor Cosby's administration, but a wider array of textual genres and artifacts. In doing so, it connects the poetry of the English Civil War with the politics of 1730s New York, analyzing the Journal's reprinted poetry and other original texts that scholars have typically not considered worthy of critical attention. The article argues that the real importance of the New-York Weekly Journal lies not simply in the Zenger trial but in its contribution to the greater public discourse of the mid-1730s New York – the discourse of disgruntled provincialism, of frustrated colonial identities, and of an emerging, if momentarily, provincial American consciousness.
You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.